Abelmajid Habibi

  Abelmajid Habibi

 

“Why do we need a Constitution? We already have the Koran, which has all the laws we need as a society.”

Abdelmajid Habibi

10 Comments

  1. Rider says:

    Aside from the translation issue I think the Koran can be quite useful. It’s the accretions that aren’t. The Koran alone maybe, the hadith, no.

  2. Ace Lightning says:

    If you substitute “Bible” for “Koran”, there are an alarming number of US politicians who would agree enthusiastically :-(

  3. rosyatrandom says:

    All you need and plenty more

  4. vrs42 says:

    If I wrote “…We already have the Bible…”, would I be smart too?

    Koran == Bright, Bible not so much?

    How is this elevating the discussion?

  5. PJ says:

    You’re being ironic/satiric/sarcastic, right? right?

  6. H. E. Parmer says:

    Given the heading, this is a joke, right?

    Although, if you substitute “Bible” (with the emphasis on “Old Testament”) for “Koran”, there’s a significant percentage of self-proclaimed Real Americans who believe exactly the same thing. (If this comes as news to anyone, I suggest they type “Dominion Theology” or “Christian Reconstructionism” into their search engine.)

    And these fanatics make no secret of their burning desire to flush (what remains of) our Constitution down the crapper. It wouldn’t be so scary if we were just talking about a fringe cult of snake-handling goobers, but this is in fact an organized and well-funded movement, with influence in Washington and the military — remember Gen. Boykin, anybody? — particularly the Air Force.

    Now there’s a pleasant thought: Apocalyptic death cultists with drones and nukes.

  7. Jay Borcherding says:

    Previous postings under the ‘bright sayings of bright people’ heading have been sincere, so I confess to being more than a little confused. You’re kidding, Fred, right? Or someone goofed?

    The moderators really ought to take a look at this, since I’m extremely doubtful that this posting genuinely reflects Fred’s beliefs.

  8. Sevesteen says:

    We need the entire constitution. We need both conservatives and liberals to accept that the constitution intentionally limits the policies they can enact and the amount of power that government can have. Instead far too many pick and choose, and search for loopholes to allow laws that the constitution clearly intended to restrict.

  9. David B. Williams says:

    Not a bright idea. All legal documents require interpretation; the US Constitution defines who can interprete it, but the Koran is an open field of endeavor; anyone who can establish themselves as a religious authority can issue interpretations. Do you want to live in a society in which Jack Van Impe can issue legal rulings, including death warrants?

    Then there’s the question of amendment. The US Constitution has a provision that defines the amendment process; the Koran does not.

  10. Tina Black says:

    Yeah, but not for a civilization.

Leave a Reply

Before you post, please prove you are sentient.

What is 9 times 6?